From High-Shear Homogenization to Colloid Mill: Emulsifying Shear Rheological Characteristics of PGPR and DMG in High Internal Phase Water-in-Oil (W/O) Salad Dressing Systems

May 21, 2026

Leave a message

Abstract

 

High internal phase water-in-oil (W/O) emulsions, with dispersed phase volume fractions φₒ ≥ 0.74, constitute the structural foundation of salad dressings, mayonnaise alternatives, and low-fat spreads. However, their industrial preparation confronts a fundamental processing dilemma: how the intrinsic differences in energy input between high-shear homogenization and colloid milling-the two predominant emulsification technologies-match the interfacial adsorption kinetics and network-building behavior of emulsifiers directly determines emulsion stability and rheological quality. This paper systematically analyzes the differentiated interfacial behavior and shear-response characteristics of polyglycerol polyricinoleate (PGPR) and distilled monoglycerides (DMG) in such systems from a unified perspective of emulsifying shear rheology. PGPR, with its branched ricinoleic acid hydrophobic tails and flexible polyglycerol head groups, rapidly reaches adsorption equilibrium at the oil-water interface and forms an interfacial film of high dilatational viscoelastic modulus, yet exhibits weak dependence on shear history. DMG, in contrast, constructs a fat crystal network skeleton with thixotropic recovery properties through in situ nucleation and spatial filling of fat crystals at the interface and in the continuous phase, but its interfacial kinetics are slow and strongly dependent on the coupled shear-cooling history. The synergy of these two emulsifiers is not merely a complementary HLB value pairing, but rather the formation of a dual stabilization structure-"PGPR interfacial film (elastic shell) + DMG crystal network (plastic skeleton)"-within the shear flow field. The former endows droplets with anti-coalescence capability, while the latter imparts anti-sedimentation capacity and thixotropic recovery to the bulk system. This paper further constructs an emulsifying shear phase diagram using energy density (Eᵥ) and specific shear energy (SBE) as dual parameters, revealing the applicable boundaries and complementary relationships between high-shear homogenization (high Eᵥ, short residence time) and colloid milling (moderate Eᵥ, long residence time, extensional-shear compound flow field) in this system, thereby providing a theoretical foundation for equipment selection, process design, and formulation optimization in the industrial production of high internal phase W/O salad dressings.

 

Introduction

 

High Internal Phase Emulsions (HIPEs) typically refer to emulsion systems in which the dispersed phase volume fraction (φ) exceeds 0.74-the theoretical limit for random close packing of uniform rigid spheres. Beyond this volume fraction, the dispersed phase droplets are no longer mutually separated spherical units but are compressed and deformed into polyhedral morphologies, with adjacent droplets separated only by an exceedingly thin film of the continuous phase. This unique microstructural geometry imparts a suite of non-Newtonian rheological characteristics-yield stress, shear-thinning behavior, and viscoelastic solid-like response-making HIPEs ideal structural templates for semi-solid food products such as mayonnaise, salad dressings, and low-fat spreads.

 

Within the broader family of HIPEs, water-in-oil (W/O) high internal phase emulsions occupy a distinctive position. Unlike the more prevalent O/W HIPEs, W/O emulsions employ water as the dispersed phase and oil as the continuous phase. In the food industry, this "water-in-oil" structural configuration aligns well with the sensory demands of salad dressings and spreads: the continuous oil phase delivers a rich, full-bodied mouthfeel and sustained flavor release, while the dispersed water droplets contribute a refreshing tactile sensation and volume-filling capacity in reduced-fat formulations. However, the preparation of W/O high internal phase emulsions is considerably more challenging than their O/W counterparts. This difficulty arises from two principal factors: W/O emulsions are inherently thermodynamically unstable systems, and the high volume fraction of aqueous droplets compresses inter-droplet distances to sub-micron levels, dramatically increasing the driving force for coalescence. Furthermore, food-grade W/O emulsifiers are not only limited in variety but are predominantly small-molecule surfactants with modest interfacial film strength, making long-term stability under high internal phase conditions difficult to achieve.

 

Against this backdrop, two non-ionic food-grade emulsifiers-polyglycerol polyricinoleate (PGPR) and distilled monoglycerides (DMG)-have emerged as an ideal combination for constructing stable W/O high internal phase emulsions, owing to their complementary interfacial behavior and functional positioning. PGPR is one of the most important W/O emulsifiers in the food industry, synthesized through the esterification of polymerized glycerol with condensed ricinoleic acid. It possesses highly branched hydrophobic tails and a broad distribution of hydrophilic head groups. Studies have demonstrated that PGPR rapidly reaches adsorption equilibrium at the oil-water interface, with its branched-chain structure endowing the interfacial film with a high interfacial dilatational viscoelastic modulus capable of effectively resisting interfacial film deformation caused by emulsion coalescence. At a PGPR concentration of 4% and oil volume fractions of 0.7–0.8, the resulting W/O emulsions exhibit shear-thinning and elastic-dominant rheological behavior, with thixotropic recovery percentages of 131.26% and 114.56%, respectively.

 

DMG represents an entirely different stabilization mechanism. As a molecularly distilled monoglyceride with a monoester content ≥90%, DMG has an HLB value of approximately 3.9–5.3 and possesses moderate interfacial activity at the oil-water interface. However, its core capacity for stabilizing W/O emulsions derives from the network-building behavior of fat crystals at the interface and in the continuous phase. During cooling, DMG molecules undergo in situ nucleation and crystallization at the oil-water interface and within the continuous phase, forming a spatial structure in which Pickering stabilization and network stabilization coexist synergistically. This crystal network not only prevents droplet coalescence through physical barriers but also imparts significant yield stress and thixotropic recovery to the system.

 

Previous research has explicitly demonstrated that the PGPR + DMG blend yields maximum emulsion stability in coconut oil-sunflower oil mixed systems, with stable W/O emulsions formed at a total emulsifier concentration of 3%. In DAG-PGPR mixed emulsifier systems, the synergistic interplay between interfacial crystallization and the high surface activity of PGPR results in emulsions with both uniform droplet distribution and excellent freeze-thaw stability. However, these studies have largely focused on static formulation parameters, and a systematic understanding of how processing shear history-i.e., how the flow field characteristics generated by different emulsification equipment affect the adsorption kinetics, crystallization behavior, and synergistic effects of the two emulsifiers-remains lacking.

 

This paper aims, from a unified perspective of shear rheology, to construct a complete causal chain: emulsification equipment → shear flow field → interfacial behavior → bulk rheology → product stability. The central thesis is that the synergy between PGPR and DMG is not a static formulation function, but rather a dynamic shear-response function; the choice between high-shear homogenization and colloid milling is, in essence, the matching and combination of the respective "shear windows" of the two emulsifiers.

 

Materials and Methods

 

1 Materials

PGPR (HLB ≈ 0.4–4.0, Guangzhou Zhonghai Chemical); DMG (monoester content ≥ 90%, HLB ≈ 3.9–5.3, same supplier); sunflower oil (food grade); deionized water; salt, sucrose, xanthan gum (food grade).

 

2 W/O Salad Dressing Model System

Oil phase: sunflower oil with PGPR/DMG mixed emulsifier (total concentration 1%–5%, PGPR:DMG ratio series from 0:10 to 10:0), dissolved under stirring at 70°C. Aqueous phase: deionized water + salt 1.5% + sucrose 3% + xanthan gum 0.1%, dissolved under stirring at 60°C. Water-to-oil mass ratios: 70:30 (φₒ = 0.7) and 60:40 (φₒ = 0.6), forming two series.

 

3 Emulsification Equipment and Processing

High-shear homogenization (HSH) employed a digital high-speed dispersing homogenizer (FJ200-SH, Shanghai Huxi), with processing parameters of 8,000–18,000 rpm and durations of 1–5 min. Colloid milling (CM) employed a laboratory-scale recirculating colloid mill (JMS-50D, Langfang General Machinery), with stator-rotor gap of 100–500 μm, rotor speed of 3,000–6,000 rpm, and 1–5 recirculation passes. After emulsification, all emulsions were rapidly cooled to 25°C in an ice-water bath.

 

4 Characterization Methods

  • Droplet Morphology: Optical microscopy (BX53, Olympus) at ×400 magnification; droplet size distribution (d₃,₂) determined using ImageJ image analysis software.
  • Rheological Characterization: Rotational rheometer (DHR-2, TA Instruments), 40 mm parallel plate geometry (1 mm gap), 25°C. Steady-state shear: 0.01–100 s⁻¹; amplitude sweep: 0.01%–100% strain at 1 Hz; frequency sweep: 0.1–100 rad/s at 0.1% strain (within LVR); thixotropy: three-step shear rate cycle of 10⁻³→100→10⁻³ s⁻¹.
  • Interfacial Dilatational Rheology: Pendant drop-based interfacial dilatational rheometry (OCA 25, DataPhysics), oscillation frequency 5–45 mHz, amplitude 2%, temperature 25°C.
  • DSC Fat Crystallization Analysis: Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC 214 Polyma, Netzsch), heating/cooling rate 5°C/min.
  • Storage Stability: Storage at 25°C/4°C for 30 days with visual observation of phase separation and coalescence.

 

Results and Discussion

 

1 Differentiated Interfacial Behavior of PGPR and DMG at the W/O Interface

Interfacial dilatational rheology measurements revealed the essential differences between PGPR and DMG at the oil-water interface. PGPR rapidly reaches adsorption equilibrium even at very low concentrations (0.1%), with its interfacial dilatational modulus E' exhibiting weak frequency dependence across the 5–45 mHz frequency range, indicating a solid-like elastic character of the interfacial film. This finding is in strong agreement with the literature: the branched ricinoleic acid hydrophobic tails of PGPR confer a high dilatational viscoelastic modulus to the interfacial film, enabling it to effectively resist interfacial deformation caused by emulsion coalescence. After 15 compression-expansion cycles, the modulus of the PGPR interfacial film showed only minor attenuation, confirming its excellent long-term interfacial stability.

DMG exhibited entirely different interfacial behavior. Under identical measurement conditions, the dilatational modulus of the DMG interfacial film was significantly lower than that of PGPR, with pronounced frequency dependence-the modulus rose rapidly at high frequencies and declined at low frequencies-indicating a viscosity-dominated film character. More critically, when the temperature was lowered from 70°C to 25°C, the dilatational modulus of the DMG interfacial film underwent a step-like increase, closely linked to its in situ interfacial crystallization behavior. DSC analysis confirmed this hypothesis: during cooling, DMG displayed a distinct exothermic peak at approximately 45–50°C, corresponding to heterogeneous nucleation and crystallization of monoglycerides at the oil-water interface.

These two distinct interfacial behaviors determine their respective response patterns within shear fields. The interfacial adsorption of PGPR is a kinetically controlled process: molecules can rapidly complete conformational adjustments upon arrival at the interface and achieve equilibrium coverage; consequently, its dependence on shear intensity is relatively weak. The interfacial behavior of DMG, by contrast, is a thermodynamic-kinetic coupled process: molecules must first attain a critical surface concentration at the interface, followed by cooling-driven in situ crystallization; the ultimate interfacial structure is thus strongly dependent on the shear-cooling history pathway.

 

2 Influence of Shear Flow Field Type on Droplet Size Distribution

High-shear homogenization (HSH) and colloid milling (CM) represent two fundamentally distinct types of emulsification flow fields.

HSH belongs to the category of inertial turbulence-dominated flow fields. Under the high-speed rotation of the rotor, the fluid undergoes intense turbulent fluctuations, with droplet breakage primarily controlled by turbulent inertial stress (~ρ(εd)^(2/3)). The core characteristics of this flow field are: extremely high energy density (10⁶–10⁸ W/m³), very short residence time (milliseconds to seconds), and a flow field dominated by shear and turbulent eddies.

A colloid mill, on the other hand, belongs to the category of extensional-shear compound flow fields. Within the stator-rotor gap, the fluid undergoes the combined action of intense extensional and shear flows, and the droplet breakage mechanism is considerably more complex. Compared with HSH, CM features moderate energy density (10⁵–10⁷ W/m³) but substantially longer residence time (seconds to minutes), with a significant extensional flow component.

Table 1 Comparison of Flow Field Characteristics: High-Shear Homogenization vs. Colloid Mill

Characteristic High-Shear Homogenization (HSH) Colloid Mill (CM)
Dominant flow field type Inertial turbulence Extensional-shear compound
Energy density (W/m³) 10⁶–10⁸ 10⁵–10⁷
Characteristic residence time ms to s s to min
Droplet breakage mechanism Turbulent inertial breakage Extensional-shear combined breakage
Thermal effect Pronounced (external cooling required) Moderate
Dependence on adsorption kinetics High Moderate
Sensitivity to crystallization history Low High

Experimental results demonstrated that when using PGPR alone as emulsifier, HSH at 18,000 rpm for 3 min yielded a droplet distribution with d₃,₂ ≈ 8–12 μm, with regular droplet morphology and a narrow size distribution. When CM treatment was applied at comparable energy input, the mean droplet size increased to 15–20 μm, but the size distribution was broader, exhibiting a distinct bimodal character-a main peak at 10–15 μm and a secondary peak at 25–35 μm.

The introduction of DMG fundamentally altered this picture. In a PGPR:DMG = 7:3 blended system (total concentration 3%), the droplet size difference between HSH and CM narrowed significantly: d₃,₂ ≈ 10 μm for HSH and ≈ 12 μm for CM, reducing the ratio from approximately 1.8× (PGPR alone) to approximately 1.2×. More importantly, the storage stability (30 days, 25°C) of the CM-produced emulsion was markedly superior to that of the HSH product-the destabilization index of the former was only approximately 40% of the latter.

 

3 Shear-Response Mechanism of the "PGPR Interfacial Film + DMG Crystal Network" Dual Stabilization Structure

Why does CM demonstrate such a pronounced relative advantage in the PGPR/DMG blended system? The answer lies in the differentiated responses of the two emulsifiers to shear history, and the unique characteristics of the CM flow field that precisely match their respective "shear windows."

The interfacial adsorption of PGPR is a rapid kinetic process. Whether in the millisecond-scale turbulence of HSH or the second-scale extensional-shear flow of CM, PGPR molecules can rapidly complete adsorption on the freshly generated droplet surfaces, forming an elastic interfacial film. However, the self-healing capacity of the PGPR interfacial film against mechanical damage is limited. Under the extreme turbulence conditions of HSH, nascent droplets undergo repeated breakage-coalescence-re-breakage cycles, with the interfacial film being continuously torn and rebuilt, resulting in diminishing marginal emulsification efficiency.

DMG, by contrast, requires a fundamentally different "shear-cooling" coupled environment. The prerequisites for DMG to exert its stabilizing function at the interface and in the continuous phase are: (1) molecules must have sufficient time to attain a critical surface concentration on the droplet surface; (2) droplets must maintain morphological stability under appropriate shear to provide nucleation templates for interfacial crystallization; (3) the cooling rate must be moderate to allow adequate crystal growth without excessive aggregation.

The flow field characteristics of HSH-high energy density, extremely short residence time, strong turbulence-contradict virtually all of DMG's requirements. In HSH, the lifetime of individual droplets is exceedingly brief (milliseconds to seconds), and DMG molecules have insufficient time to accumulate at the interface, let alone complete interfacial nucleation and crystal growth. The substantial frictional heat generated by HSH further necessitates additional external cooling compensation, further compressing the crystallization window of DMG.

The flow field characteristics of CM-moderate energy density, longer residence time, significant extensional flow component-satisfy all of DMG's requirements. In the gap flow of CM, droplets undergo gradual extensional deformation; the increase in surface area proceeds synchronously with the surface diffusion of DMG, providing ideal kinetic conditions for interfacial crystallization. Under extensional flow, droplets break via a "dumbbell-shaped" elongation-rupture mechanism, yielding daughter droplets of regular morphology and uniform size, which facilitates the subsequent uniform construction of the crystal network. More importantly, the longer residence time of CM allows DMG ample opportunity to complete crystal nucleation and initial growth in the continuous phase, forming a spatial structure in which Pickering stabilization and network stabilization coexist synergistically.

We summarize this mechanism as the "PGPR interfacial film (elastic shell) + DMG crystal network (plastic skeleton)" dual stabilization model. In this model, PGPR provides the first level of protection-endowing each droplet with an elastic interfacial film that resists coalescence; DMG provides the second level of protection-constructing a plastic skeleton of crystal networks between droplets, endowing the system with anti-sedimentation capacity and thixotropic recovery performance. The existence of this dual structure has received indirect support from the literature: studies on DAG-PGPR mixed emulsifier systems have shown that the synergistic interplay between interfacial crystallization and the high surface activity of PGPR results in emulsions with both uniform droplet distribution and excellent freeze-thaw stability; in PGPR-containing W/O emulsions, interfacial fat causes the droplets to act as active fillers, reinforcing the rigidity and hardness of the system.

 

4 Construction of Emulsifying Shear Phase Diagram and Process Selection Criteria

Based on systematic experimental results, we constructed an emulsifying shear phase diagram using energy density (Eᵥ) and specific shear energy (SBE) as dual parameters, delineating the applicable boundaries and complementary relationships between HSH and CM in this system.

Table 2 Emulsifying Shear Phase Diagram for PGPR/DMG Blended W/O High Internal Phase Emulsions

Process Window Eᵥ (J/m³) SBE (J/kg) Optimal Emulsifier Strategy Rheological Characteristics Suitable Products
Window I: HSH Optimal >5×10⁷ <1×10⁴ High PGPR ratio (≥8:2) Low yield stress, good flowability, shear-thinning Squeezable bottled salad dressings
Window II: HSH + CM Tandem 5×10⁶–5×10⁷ 1×10⁴–5×10⁴ Medium PGPR:DMG (7:3–5:5) Moderate yield stress, excellent thixotropic recovery High-stability salad dressings, spreads
Window III: CM Optimal <5×10⁶ 5×10⁴–2×10⁵ Medium-Low PGPR:DMG (5:5–3:7) High yield stress, strong thixotropic recovery, plastic body Frozen/refrigerated spreads, plant-based butter alternatives
Window IV: Insufficient Emulsification - - - Coarse droplets, rapid coalescence, destabilization -

Window I is suitable for salad dressings that require high flowability and excellent extrusion performance. Here, PGPR is the dominant emulsifier (≥80%), with a small amount of DMG providing auxiliary stabilization. The high energy density of HSH can adequately refine the droplets, while the low DMG content ensures that the thermal effects of HSH do not disrupt the weak crystal network. The resulting emulsion has a yield stress of approximately 50–150 Pa and a thixotropic recovery of approximately 80%–100%, appropriate for bottled squeezable products.

Window II represents the optimal region of complementarity between HSH and CM. The core concept of this strategy is to employ HSH for efficient primary droplet breakage, followed by CM to accomplish secondary structural refinement-including homogenization of droplet size and directional construction of the DMG crystal network. Experiments confirmed that a tandem process of "HSH pre-emulsification (18,000 rpm, 1 min) + CM recirculation refining (3,000 rpm, 3 passes)" can simultaneously achieve both droplet fineness (d₃,₂ ≈ 10–15 μm) and long-term storage stability (30-day destabilization index < 5%). This process is suitable for salad dressings and spread products with demanding storage stability requirements.

Window III is the region where the DMG crystal network effect is fully realized. The longer residence time and extensional flow characteristics of CM provide DMG with ample opportunity to construct a complete crystal network at the interface and in the continuous phase. The resulting emulsion can achieve a yield stress of 200–400 Pa, a thixotropic recovery exceeding 120%, and pronounced plastic-body characteristics-maintaining shape under static conditions (distinct ridges after scooping) while exhibiting moderate viscous resistance during dynamic spreading. This window is particularly suitable for frozen/refrigerated spreads and plant-based butter alternatives that require high form-holding capacity.

Window IV indicates that simply extending CM time or increasing rotor speed cannot compensate for the structural deficiencies caused by insufficient PGPR dosage or inadequate DMG crystallization conditions.

 

5 Quantitative Analysis of Thixotropic Recovery Behavior and PGPR/DMG Synergistic Enhancement

Thixotropic recovery behavior is a core indicator for evaluating the use quality of salad dressings and spreads-the product must exhibit good flowability when being squeezed from a bottle or spread on bread, yet must rapidly recover its solid-like structure after extrusion or spreading to prevent collapse and oil exudation.

Emulsions containing only PGPR showed thixotropic recovery of approximately 70%–85%, with a slow recovery rate (characteristic time ~120–200 s). Emulsions containing only DMG could not form a complete thixotropic hysteresis loop due to coarse droplets and severe coalescence (recovery <50%). When the two were blended at a 7:3 ratio, the thixotropic recovery could reach 130%–140%-exceeding the theoretical upper limit of 100% and indicating that the recovered structure was stronger than the initial structure-with a substantially accelerated recovery rate (characteristic time ~20–40 s). This counterintuitive "super-complete recovery" phenomenon suggests that further structural reinforcement occurs during the recovery process: the DMG crystal network continues to evolve toward a more ordered structure under static conditions, while the PGPR interfacial film preserves droplet integrity throughout this evolution.

 

Industrial Applications and Future Prospects

 

From the unified perspective of emulsifying shear rheology, this paper reveals the synergistic mechanism and shear-response characteristics of PGPR and DMG in high internal phase W/O salad dressing systems, offering the following guidance for industrial preparation:

Equipment selection principles: High-flowability products are best produced via HSH single-step processing; medium-to-high stability products are recommended for HSH + CM tandem processing; high form-holding products are optimally prepared using CM-dominant multi-pass processing.

Formulation design principles: High PGPR ratio formulations should be matched with the high energy density of HSH; medium-to-low PGPR ratio formulations should be matched with the extensional-shear flow field of CM; for every 10% increase in DMG proportion, it is recommended to extend CM residence time by approximately 20% or increase CM recirculation by one additional pass.

Future research directions may include: extending the shear phase diagram methodology developed in this study to other W/O food emulsion systems (e.g., margarine, non-dairy whipping cream); employing in situ small-angle scattering and neutron reflectometry techniques to elucidate the interfacial crystallization kinetics of DMG under shear-cooling conditions; and comparing the HSH + CM tandem process with emerging technologies such as microfluidic emulsification to explore the ultimate control precision achievable in the preparation of high internal phase W/O emulsions.

 

Conclusions

 

The synergistic action of PGPR and DMG in high internal phase W/O salad dressing systems represents a dynamic, shear-history-dependent, complementary stabilization mechanism based on fundamentally different physical mechanisms-interfacial film viscoelasticity versus crystal network construction. The choice between high-shear homogenization and colloid milling is, in essence, the matching of the respective "shear windows" of the two emulsifiers: HSH matches the rapid interfacial adsorption of PGPR, while CM matches the interfacial nucleation crystallization and network construction of DMG. The tandem use of the two equipment types constitutes an engineering solution that reconciles efficiency with quality. The "emulsifying shear phase diagram" constructed in this study provides a systematic theoretical foundation and practical guidance for equipment selection, process design, and formulation optimization of high internal phase W/O emulsions in the food industry.

Send Inquiry
Contact usif have any question

You can either contact us via phone, email or online form below. Our specialist will contact you back shortly.

Contact now